In 2013 St. James Pizza opened its’ doors with the intention of bringing a little bit of Brooklyn to Long Island. Once tasting the food, I’m sure you will understand why.
Owner Sal Cafisi, who has been in the food business for 20 years, is proud to tell you that the recipes they use have been passed down from generation to generation. This is what brings authenticity to this old-fashioned pizzeria. The pizza crust is to die for – not too thin, crisp, and made just perfect.  The dough is made in small batches to ensure its freshness. The sauce? Made fresh, every day. It’s a combination of Sicilian, house sauce, grandma, and pizza sauce. That’s what sets St. James Pizzeria apart from most Italian eateries.
Not only are they known for outstanding pizza, but they also offer an exquisite menu to match. Entrees range from chicken marsala and cacciatore to a mouthwatering mozzarella and roasted bacon cheeseburger, along with eggplant, veal and seafood options. St. James Pizza also has delicious pasta dishes, heros, and paninis to choose from.
And don’t forget about dessert – fresh, sumptuous zeppoles that melt in your mouth, and are a sweet finish to any meal. St. James Pizza offers free delivery, daily lunch specials and an extensive catering menu. If you like, you can design a menu to fit your specific needs and budget.
As Sal puts it, “our reputation is only as good as how customers feel about our food and service.” Here are just a few comments from our customers that really tells the tale.
Shana - “Best pizza I’ve ever had, fresh, hot and quick delivery.”
Kurt - “The eggplant rollatine pizza was AMAZING!!! I had pizza for three days and it was just as delivious on day three.”
Odalisse - “So good! Their personal pizzas arre yummy and a good size.”
Anne - “I love St. James Pizza! Their employees are friendly and the service is excellent. I love their soups, homemade and delicious.”
St. James Pizza is located at 739 Middle Country Road, St. James and can be reached at 631-979-9600. Visit our website www.stjamespizza.com. Don’t forget - St. James Pizza is “A Slice above the Rest!” Fuhgettaboutit!